vpopmail aliases: virtualmin's "additional email addresses for user" broken with mysql backend

Speaking of vpopmail...

Unless it's me having "finger trouble", vpopmail+mysql+virtualmin+mail aliases = broken. Many standard virtualmail installs use mysql - and this means this issue is a bug not a feature request.

For the sake of sanity - I had erased my vpopmail mysql tables - all of them deleted the domain and started over. All the configuration that lead to this breakage is courtesy of virtualmin ;)

FYI The configuration options for how gentoo compiles vpopmail is in an ebuild file on packages.gentoo.org. If that's too much trouble, here's what the configuration arguments are during compiling.

" ./configure --prefix=/usr --build=x86_64-pc-linux-gnu --host=x86_64-pc-linux-gnu --mandir=/usr/share/man --infodir=/usr/share/info --datadir=/usr/share --sysconfdir=/etc --localstatedir=/var/lib --libdir=/usr/lib64 --disable-dependency-tracking --enable-incdir=/usr/include/mysql --enable-auth-module=mysql --enable-libdir=/usr/lib64/mysql --enable-sql-logging --enable-valias --disable-mysql-replication --enable-mysql-limits --sysconfdir=/var/vpopmail/etc --enable-non-root-build --enable-qmaildir=/var/qmail --enable-qmail-newu=/var/qmail/bin/qmail-newu --enable-qmail-inject=/var/qmail/bin/qmail-inject --enable-qmail-newmrh=/var/qmail/bin/qmail-newmrh --enable-vpopuser=vpopmail --enable-vpopgroup=vpopmail --enable-many-domains --enable-file-locking --enable-file-sync --enable-md5-passwords --enable-logging --enable-auth-logging --enable-log-name=vpopmail --enable-qmail-ext --disable-tcpserver-file --disable-roaming-users --enable-ip-alias-domains --enable-clear-passwd --disable-maildrop --disable-maildrop-prog --enable-spamassassin"

At least on my system, Spamassassin and maildrop can cause problems, but I disable those features in the SQL. That is the same as a .qmail-limits file qmailadmin would make in the root of the domain. Supporting the limits file would also be a nice feature request for webmin, well more to the point defining the limits through vmoduser is the way to implement it, as it would apply the settings to ldap /mysql instances of vpopmail too.

NB: Real domain names changed to lame ones in the examples below.

crm domains # valias -s hifive.biz abuse@hifive.biz -> postmaster@hifive.biz hostmaster@hifive.biz -> postmaster@hifive.biz support@hifive.biz -> | /var/vpopmail/bin/vdelivermail '' cs@hifive.biz snip this is the issue ^^^ webmaster@hifive.biz -> hifive@hifive.biz

Notice the domain administrator account (hifive@hifive.biz) was not created by virtualmin! Yet appears in virtual min panel. Another issue....

Lets test delivery of mail aliases created with a virtualmin user panel's "Additional Email Addresses"

Test mail from me@mail.ru -> support@hifive.biz on its way...

crm domains # jobs [1]+ Running tail -f /var/log/qmail/qmail-send/current &

crm domains # @40000000501c681d1262ac34 new msg 6103593 @40000000501c681d1262b7ec info msg 6103593: bytes 1671 from me@mail.ru qp 10834 uid 201 @40000000501c681d12634874 starting delivery 20: msg 6103593 to local hifive.biz-support@hifive.biz @40000000501c681d12635044 status: local 1/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c681f379e6934 delivery 20: deferral: vdelivermail:_deferred,_database_down/ @40000000501c681f379e7104 status: local 0/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c688301e1ba44 starting delivery 21: msg 6103593 to local hilfive.biz-support@hifive.biz @40000000501c688301e1c5fc status: local 1/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c68852329c32c delivery 21: deferral: vdelivermail:_deferred,_database_down/ @40000000501c68852329cee4 status: local 0/25 remote 0/50

Not happy with the virtualmin created alias! Pipes are not deliverable I believe in mysql valias - standard on gentoo with mysql backed virtualmin. There are NO .qmail-support file in /var/vpopmail/domains/hifive.biz/ - this is because aliases have moved to SQL and are not handed with all the same semantics of dot-qmail files.

Now here is with a more conventional alias (the abuse@hifive.biz - also created by virtualmin without a "|" pipe in the alias line)

@40000000501c6aa60d47ae5c info msg 6107723: bytes 2164 from me@mail.ru qp 13864 uid 201 @40000000501c6aa60d4842cc starting delivery 26: msg 6107723 to local hifive.biz-abuse@hifive.biz @40000000501c6aa60d4846b4 status: local 1/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6aa60ed19a1c delivery 26: success: vdelivermail:_valiases_processed/did_0+0+1/ @40000000501c6aa60ed3cc9c status: local 0/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6aa60ed3d46c new msg 6115473 @40000000501c6aa60ed3d854 info msg 6115473: bytes 2263 from SRS0=/4YGe0=GE=mail.ru=mememe@srs.hifive.biz qp 13870 uid 89 @40000000501c6aa60ed445b4 starting delivery 27: msg 6115473 to local hifive.biz-postmaster@hifive.biz @40000000501c6aa60ed4499c status: local 1/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6aa60ed58dd4 end msg 6107723 @40000000501c6aa61039ffd4 delivery 27: success: did_0+0+1/ @40000000501c6aa6103ce9ec status: local 0/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6aa6103e41ac end msg 6115473 q@40000000501c6b1716346514 starting delivery 28: msg 6103597 to local hifive.biz-postmaster@hifive.biz @40000000501c6b17163470cc status: local 1/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6b17178ca9e4 delivery 28: success: did_0+0+1/ @40000000501c6b17178f49c4 status: local 0/25 remote 0/50 @40000000501c6b171790dc1c end msg 6103597

The message got delivered. The SRS stuff is forced on for local MDA's not using the host's send as addresss, just ignore it. It means that the valias (mysql) handling module in vpopmail is using /var/qmail/bin/qmail-inject to do it's mailforwarding for all aliases.

I need to look over the vpopmail code to work out the scope of this bug, and see what kind of alias entries (forward, pipe, local mailbox etc) it can handle. .... DONE... looks like user@domain.tld only with support for qmail extensions (optional) eg luke-lists-virtualmin@domain.tld being correctly handled by aliases.

valias -i just inserts whatever data you throw at it. It's structure is as follows. alias char(32) NO MUL domain char(96) NO
valias_line text NO

I would look at process_valias(void) in vdelivermail - i think this bug could affect more than just SQL backended vpopmail installs. vdelivermail.c on my system (gentoo patched up version) attached.

My version is slightly different - it calls maildrop -d user@xyz.com to do the deliveries, and always runs under vpopmail. maildrop is suid, and vpopmail is hacked to always use uid/gid 89. deliverable is just the alias looker-upper, but can still support domain based filesystem quotas. vpopmail domain quotas are broken.

If I get the my implementation of vpopmail+mysql+maildrop+[no]mailscript+spamc that supports user level anti-virus scanning (virtualmin's way) it would be a nice addition to virtualmin. Would you give then give your corporate users a choice to run qmail or postfix, and distribute packages for the both. I guess and ebuild could be converted to src.deb / src.rpms and hosted on your repository for subscribed customers.

THINK PLESK - and their patched up version of qmail has all the same features my patched up version of qmail supports. This would be a step forwards to making a more plesk migration friendly product.

Suggested fix:

don't use "|/var/vpopmail/bin/vdelivermail '' user@domain.tld" to forward mail anymore. Let qmail do the conventional way even if has to spawn some more processes.



Please make the changes...

--- feature-mail.pl.orig 2012-08-04 02:16:12.387122113 +0000
+++ feature-mail.pl 2012-08-04 02:20:35.202868090 +0000
@@ -1838,7 +1838,10 @@
# Create with valias command
local $qfrom = quotemeta("$box\@$dom");
foreach $t (@{$_[0]->{'to'}}) {
- local $qto = quotemeta(&vpopmail_to_qmail($t, $dom));
+ # see https://www.virtualmin.com/node/22970
+ # vpopmail doesn't support dot-qmail parsing in ldap/mysql valiases
+ # local $qto = quotemeta(&vpopmail_to_qmail($t, $dom));
+ local $qto = quotemeta("$t\@$dom");
local $cmd = "$vpopbin/valias -i $qto $qfrom";
local $out = &backquote_logged("$cmd 2>&1");

Let's test it with a newly created user.

@40000000501c87c3216cb594 info msg 6115475: bytes 3751 from qp 5400 uid 201
@40000000501c87c3216cb97c starting delivery 48: msg 6115475 to local hihi.biz-russianmonkey@hihi.biz
@40000000501c87c3216cc14c status: local 2/25 remote 0/50
@40000000501c87c323234ed4 delivery 48: success: vdelivermail:_valiases_processed/did_0+0+1/
@40000000501c87c323270024 status: local 1/25 remote 0/50
@40000000501c87c323270bdc end msg 6115475
@40000000501c87c3232c91ec new msg 6129733
@40000000501c87c3232c99bc info msg 6129733: bytes 3860 from qp 5490 uid 89
@40000000501c87c3232ca18c starting delivery 49: msg 6129733 to local hihi.biz-shurik@hihi.biz
@40000000501c87c3232ca574 status: local 2/25 remote 0/50
@40000000501c87c32516a6dc new msg 6115475
@40000000501c87c32516b294 info msg 6115475: bytes 3959 from qp 5502 uid 89
@40000000501c87c32517337c starting delivery 50: msg 6115475 to remote shurik@gimap.hihi.biz
@40000000501c87c325173764 status: local 2/25 remote 1/50
@40000000501c87c325437784 delivery 49: success: did_0+0+1/

Yep, the Russian monkey got his mail twice, once in his mail box and once in his gmail. I can now delegate sign-ups and management of user email to the staff.

When you are not using vpopmail and virtualmin I would recommend putting a & in front of a forward in a .qmail file. Alternatively do some regex ^[a-z][0-9] if that matches on the string you can leave out the ampersand in .qmail files. I don't think virtualmin adheres to this - see dot-qmail man page. The developers on the mailing list say & is supported in aliases (with valias i mysql) though I could be wrong.

vpopmail is designed to be web administered, so all additions to the database in theory can be done through SQL, and there is no need to call all the vpopmail binaries unless you want to. Of course if you want to delete mailboxes you need to get their hands dirty and unlik the files manually.

----- Original Message -----
From: "Ken Jones"
Sent: Thursday, September 09, 2004 3:48 AM
Subject: Re: [vchkpw] vpopmail + billing server integration
> On Wednesday 08 September 2004 12:25 pm, Chris Ess wrote:
> > On Wed, 8 Sep 2004, Ken Jones wrote:
> > > Hi,
> > >
> > > Here is something we built into vpopmail for sites like yours.
> > >
> > > Use mysql on the email server. Have the billing system
> > > insert an entry in the vpopmail table, leaving the directory
> > > field blank. vpopmail will automatically create the users
> > > directory and update the database when any program
> > > tries to deliver mail to the user, or authenticate as the user.
> >
> > That's really neat! I didn't realize you could do this. (Now someone
> > will tell me that it's in the documentation that I seem to've not read
> > recently.)
> It is probably in the mailing list archives. I'm not sure if anyone has
> updated the documentation.
> >
> > (I know this is getting offtopic...) So I could use an INSERT statement in
> > SQL instead of vadduser? Or am I not understanding this correctly?
> That is the idea. A while back some folks wanted to hook up their billing
> systems to vpopmail. Basicly they would insert into the vpopmail sql table.
> The only thing they couldn't do easily was create the hashed directory path.
> So we put in vpopmail code to check if the path is blank and automatically
> create the new path and update the database.
> You will also need to set the encrypted password using mysql's CRYPT function.
> Mysql's standard encryption functions are not compatible with unix/linux.
> Ken

Look at qmailadmin. Let's make a new class of mailserver virtualmin supports: qmail-vpopmail-mysql.


I've added a request for more information to the vpopmail mailing list about this breakage in mysql backed versions of vpopmail having vdelivermail pipe a email to itself.
Hopefully this clarifies what is going on.

Subject: valias line that pipes into vdelivermail again breaks delivery /
valias documentation lax
From: Luke vpopmail
To: vchkpw@inter7.com

Hi Guys,

I've been a Qmail users since Peter Samuel at SLUG.org.au did his talk a
long long time ago.

Now down to business. I have an issue with vpopmail failing with
virtualmin, a webmin spin off..

Basically what happening is this, virtualmin is configuring
|/var/vpopmail/bin/vdelivermail user@domain for aliases and it's breaking.
Why it's breaking I don't exactly know why, because according to the valias
code pipes are supported.

I seek confirmation on the mysql implementation of vmail aliases.

* multiple aliases for the same domain are supported (true)
* if qmail extensions are used (user-ext@domain) in aliases they will be
used INSTEAD of the user's alias (?)
* qmail extensions are supported on aliases if there is not a better match
(see above)
? how do qmail extensions on aliases flow through to the user accounts ?
* pipes are supported (true) (see caveat)
* &forwarding is supported - in order to support non-standard email naming
conventions i.e. dot qmail compliancy (true?)
* mbox delivery is not supported (true)
* if no hostname is provided on alias it will use
/var/qmail/control/defaultdelivery (true? seems to be using
/var/qmail/bin/qmail-inject at some point noenvhost is ignored)
* aliases are processed before users (true)
* if the database is down, a soft delivery delay occurs (true)
* mail loops for valiases only are detected (true) (not for user accounts
bouncing back to a valias??)
* delivery to maildir folders are supported if the full path is specified
* delivery to maildir folders are supported for relative paths in relation
to vpopmail's home directory defined in /etc/passwd (true?) i.e. ./domains/
hiled.biz/user/.maildir/ is prepended by vpopmail's home directory
* a maildir folder needs a ./ or a / at the beginning of the line to be
processed (true/false?)
* anything else that should go into the readme file thats not there....

I do hope some people can look at that virtualmin ticket to theorize why
vdelivermail doesn't like calling itself to do another delivery.
The issue doesn't affect me, it's just that some other setup's and indeed
virtualmin's non-sql-backend setups are all doing it this way.
It did take day to hunt down, but finally my pain is over (i never thought
of checking the valias database)

I'm also petitioning virtualmin to be fixed fixed to work with gentoo's
defacto .maildir defaultdelivery standard for qmail. They had hardcoded
./Maildir in their source.

Speaking of the maildrop patch for virtualmin, I don't like it in it's
current form. It's messy.
I think that vpopmail should support this setup instead.

1) If a domain is not owned by vpopmail:vckpwd/vpopmail still configure
/var/qmail/users/assign to use uid/gid 89 (vpopmail) - see below, this
should be configured by a #ifdef MAILDROP
2) Add maildrop to your system as SUID with it set up that vpopmail is a
trusted user. --configure-trusted-users=x,y,z,vpopmail in maildrop
configure script.
[ Due to the amount of personal information vpopmail system could release,
it should be pretty locked down anyway if any system administrator is worth
his salt.]
3) I patched vdelivermail to spawn vpopmail in LDA mode.
--- vdelivermail.c.orig 2012-08-03 06:51:43.397294158 +0000
+++ vdelivermail.c 2012-08-03 07:56:38.802799846 +0000
@@ -409,7 +409,7 @@
if ( limits.disable_maildrop==0 && vpw!=NULL &&
!(vpw->pw_gid & NO_MAILDROP) ) {
- sprintf(maildrop_command, "| preline %s", MAILDROP_PROG);
+ sprintf(maildrop_command, "| preline %s -a -d %s@%s", MAILDROP_PROG,
TheUser, TheDomain);
DeleteMail = 1;
This way maildrop sets up the home directory, the maildir directory and the
appropriate user ID tself. You can still have site-wide configuration by
4) To make point #3 working you need courier-authlib working. They have
just recently the removed vpopmail authentication backend. However SQL /
LDAP or whatever vpopmail uses can be queried. Here is an an example for

#address of mysql server
MYSQL_SERVER localhost

#login for mysql

#password for mysql
# of course i don't use the default password ^%%
#path to mysql socket
MYSQL_SOCKET /var/run/mysqld/mysqld.sock

#mysql port

#mysql options (leave alone)

#name of mysql database
#mysql charset to use

#default domain to use, when no domain is supplied by user

#MYSQL_CLEAR_PWFIELD pw_clear_passwsd
#MYSQL_LOGIN_FIELD CONCAT(pw_name, '@', pw_domain)
#ISNUMERIC(pw_shell) AS quota,

MYSQL_SELECT_CLAUSE SELECT CONCAT(pw_name, '@', pw_domain) AS username,
pw_passwd AS cryptpw, \
pw_clear_passwd AS clearpw, \
if (pw_uid = '0','89',pw_uid) AS uid, \
if (pw_uid = '0','89',pw_gid) AS gid, \
pw_dir AS home, \
CONCAT(pw_dir, '/.maildir/') AS maildir, \
if (pw_shell = 'NOQUOTA', '', pw_shell) AS quota, \
pw_gecos AS fullname, \
'disablewebmail=0,disablepop3=0,disableimap=0' AS
options \
FROM vpopmail WHERE \
pw_name = '$(local_part)' AND pw_domain =

username, \
pw_passwd AS cryptpw, \
pw_clear_passwd AS clearpw, \
if (pw_uid = '0','89',pw_uid) AS uid, \
if (pw_uid = '0','89',pw_gid) AS gid, \
pw_dir AS home, \
CONCAT(pw_dir, '/.maildir/') AS maildir, \
if (pw_shell = 'NOQUOTA', '', pw_shell) AS quota, \
pw_gecos AS fullname, \
'disablewebmail=0,disablepop3=0,disableimap=0' AS
options \
FROM vpopmail;

SET pw_clear_passwd='$(newpass)', \
pw_passwd='$(newpass_crypt)' \
WHERE pw_name='$(local_part)' \
AND pw_domain = '$(domain)' ;

I think pw_gid should be hardcoded as 89, though it shouldn't matter as all
mail is umasked 007 anyway.

As you can see it works.
crm authlib # authtest user@hiled.biz
Authentication succeeded.

Authenticated: user@hiled.biz (uid 89, gid 89)
Home Directory: /var/vpopmail/domains/hiled.biz/user
Maildir: /var/vpopmail/domains/hiled.biz/user/.maildir/
Quota: 536870912S

Should I have a / on the end of the .maildir in maildrop? I've seen
examples of it not there.
Now I can have some scripting (per site and per user) before the real LDA -
from dovecot gets called. No messy configuration in vpopmail either.

What do you think? Can the maildrop patch be updated to be less of a hack
and more of a real LDA, to have it called the same way it is from courier /



Bug confirmed. Jamie: Apply suggested fix to virtualmin.

On Mon, Aug 6, 2012 at 3:28 AM, Tom Collins tom@tomlogic.com wrote:

Haven't read your whole email, so I apologize if I'm off base.

vdelivermail should only go in .qmail-default. It should not go in .qmail-alias files. If you're using it there, you will have problems.

(Sent from my phone; forgive my brevity)


Follow the thread here.

So do you have a patch to Virtualmin for this issue? If so, it may be better to email it to me at jcameron@virtualmin.com , so that it doesn't get mangled by the bug tracker.

See comment #2 it's a one-liner patch you are looking for.

Be careful where vpopmail_qmail() is called. It must not be used in conjuction with valias. In actual dot-qmail files OK, but it will break if injected into valias -i

valias without mysql backend does that, use .qmail files. Vpopmail mailing list people reconmend that vdelivermail only be called once per virtual domain, i.e. in the .qmail-default file - not per user.

Audit your code to ensure that the offending funciton is only used to create the .qmail-default file, or edit such a file. Any aliases to be created with valias -i

Check the source and my mail above on the limitations of valias, but I suggest just putting email addresses only. If email addresses first character doesn't match [a-z][A-Z][0-9] you are required to add a & first. See man dot-qmail.